班门弄斧的一帖：Rainbow Trout vs Steelhead 有什么不同和联系

[wetnose]

班门弄斧的一帖：Rainbow Trout vs Steelhead 有什么不同和联系。

说句实在的话，在参加这个多伦多钓鱼论坛之前，钓了十几年的鱼了，光听别人说Rainbow Trout 和Steelhead，从来也没有问过别人这Rainbow Trout 和Steelhead 有什么区别和联系，刚刚在网上查了一下，看完以后我是似懂非懂了，把整篇文章放到这里，欢迎院长，阿迪，姜太公，阿华，枫叶等补充指正！

What is the difference between a Rainbow Trout and a Steelhead?

If you check the Ontario Ministry of Natural Resource’s (OMNR) fishing regulations, you will not find Steelhead listed. Instead you’ll simply find Rainbow Trout. The distinction between Rainbow Trout and Steelhead is often a source of confusion among novice and casual anglers.

steelheadrainbowtrout.jpg

Steelhead are often referred to as “sea-run”, or as is the case in Ontario, “lake-run” Rainbow Trout.

A Steelhead is an “anadromous” Rainbow Trout. In other words, a Steelhead is a Rainbow Trout that migrates from the tributary waters where it hatched, out to sea, or in this case, one of Ontario’s Great Lakes to mature. Once in the large body of water, Steelhead growth rates rapidly accelerate. They are able to attain much larger sizes than would be possible had they remained in their birth stream.

Non-anadromous Rainbow Trout or “Resident Rainbow Trout” on the other hand, remain in their native rivers and streams throughout their entire life cycle and do not migrate out to the Great Lakes. Because of this, Resident Rainbow Trout remain small relative to Steelhead. Steelhead and Rainbow Trout are however genetically the same species of fish.

Steelhead offspring are capable of converting into Resident Rainbow Trout if an event occurs that blocks access to the larger body of water, such as the erection of a dam. Similarly, Resident Rainbow Trout offspring are capable of migrating to a larger body of water if it becomes accessible and/or if conditions in the resident stream become unfavorable.

One parent of each type, Steelhead and Resident Rainbow Trout, can produce offspring of both types.

[wetnose]

另外的一篇有点像论文，很长啊！
General Description
Rainbow and steelhead trout are the most widely known trout in the world and are highly sought after by anglers because of their strong fighting abilities. In Alaska, there are two commonly recognized forms of the rainbow trout and these sub-groupings or “forms” are based primarily on where they spend their time feeding and maturing. The most common rainbow trout in Alaska is the stream-resident form that lives its life entirely in freshwater with maybe short periods of time spent in estuarine or near-shore marine waters. The second form is commonly known as steelhead and these rainbow trout leave freshwater as juveniles and migrate long distances in the ocean where they grow to maturity before migrating back to their original home waters.

Since rainbow and steelhead trout are the same species there are no major physical differences between them, however, the nature of their differing lifestyles has resulted in subtle differences in color, shape, size, and general appearance. Juvenile steelhead are indistinguishable from juvenile rainbow trout during the first few years of their life. Young trout have eight to thirteen parr marks on their sides and five to ten parr marks between the top of the head and dorsal fin. The adipose fin usually has a continuous outline of black surrounded by a clear window and the lower jaw (maxillary) typically does not extend past the back margin of the eye. Prior to their seaward migration juvenile steelhead go through a series of physical changes called smoltification which allows them to survive in saltwater; during this process the fish lose their parr marks and become silvery in color.

Within a year or so of hatching the stream resident form of rainbow trout possess the well-known streamlined salmonid form, though body shape and coloration vary widely and reflect habitat, age, sex, and degree of maturity. The body shape may range from slender to thick. The back may shade from blue-green to olive. There is a reddish-pink band along each side about the midline that may range from faint to radiant. The lower sides are usually silver, fading to pure white beneath. Small black spots are present over the back above the lateral line, as well as on the upper fins and tail. In some locations, the black spots of adults may extend well below the lateral line and even cover the entire lower side. Rainbow trout are positively identified by the 8 to 12 rays in the anal fin, a mouth that does not extend past the back of the eye, and the lack of teeth at the base of the tongue. River or stream residents normally display the most intense pink stripe coloration and heaviest spotting followed by rainbows from lake and lake-stream systems. Spawning trout are characterized by generally darker coloration.

Adult steelhead which have spent 1 to 3 years in the ocean are generally heavily spotted with irregularly shaped dark spots both above and below the lateral line. Small spots are also scattered along the top of the head, along the sides, on the dorsal and both lobes of the caudal fins. Steelhead are typically silvery or brassy in color but may range from steely blue and emerald green to olive. Steelhead fresh from the ocean can be very bright and much more silver in color than resident rainbow. The classic band of color along the lateral line, which rainbow trout are named for, can range from light pink to deep red with mature males having the brightest colors. Although typically larger in size, steelhead are generally more slender and streamlined than stream resident rainbow trout. On steelhead the typical colors and spots of the trout appear to be coming from beneath a dominant silvery sheen which gradually fades in fresh water and steelhead become difficult to differentiate from mature resident rainbow trout. The distinct and beautiful coloration of steelhead during the freshwater spawning period is important for mating and reproduction while the silvery sheen and streamlined shape of ocean-bright steelhead is essential to survival in the ocean environment.

Stream resident rainbow trout and juvenile steelhead can usually be distinguished from their close relative the cutthroat trout because rainbow trout do not have the classic red or “cutthroat” slash on the underside of their lower jaw. However not all cutthroat trout have this slash and there are naturally occurring rainbow/cutthroat trout hybrids which have physical markings of both. Biologists often use the presence/absence of small teeth at the base of the tongue called basibranchial teeth as a means to distinguish between steelhead (teeth absent) and cutthroat trout (teeth present).

[wetnose]

Life History
Growth and Reproduction
During late winter or early spring, when water temperatures rise, the maturing adult rainbow trout and steelhead usually seek out the shallow gravel riffles or a suitable clearwater stream. Spawning takes place in the spring from late March through early July as daily water temperatures reach 6 – 90 C. The female uses her tail to prepare a redd, or nest, 4 to 12 inches deep and 10 to 15 inches in diameter. From 200 to 8,000 eggs are deposited in the redd, fertilized by a male, and covered with gravel. Hatching normally takes place from a few weeks to as much as four months after spawning, depending upon the water temperature. A few more weeks may be required for the tiny fry to emerge from the gravel.

Age and growth of rainbow and steelhead trout are controlled by complex interactions of genetics and environmental conditions. The onset of sexual maturity varies markedly between individuals due primarily to such factors as food availability, population density, water temperature, productivity of the aquatic environment, and genetic makeup. In small streams, rainbow trout may spawn at 2 or 3 years of age and males often mature a year before females. Mature steelhead have generally spent 3 years in freshwater before migrating to the ocean and then another 2 years feeding in the ocean before they return to spawn. Once maturity is reached trout may spawn annually or skip a year or two before spawning again. Rainbow trout up to age 11 have been observed spawning.

Among resident rainbow trout, those living in or migrating to large lakes with sockeye salmon runs generally grow faster and larger than fish which remain year round in streams.

When compared to the mundane habits of resident trout, steelhead have a very complicated and diverse life history. Juvenile steelhead smolt and begin their emigration to saltwater during late April through the middle of June. Once in the marine environment the steelhead grow rapidly because of the abundance of food and can grow an inch per month until they return to their natal streams as mature adults. Steelhead will have moved hundreds of miles into open ocean before returning to their natal stream to spawn. Most steelhead return after 2 or 3 years but a few may return after just one year and some not until 4 years. The oldest known-aged steelhead in Alaska is an 11-year fish from the Situk River which spent 5 years rearing in freshwater followed by 6 years in the ocean; the number of times this fished spawned is unknown.

Steelhead are often grouped or classified as to the time of year they return to their home waters or natal stream, i.e., spring, summer or fall. Spring-run steelhead return to streams in Alaska between March and early June while the rare summer-run fish will return to freshwater during July. Fall-run steelhead enter the freshwater systems as adults in August through October and possibly throughout the winter. Regardless of when they return to freshwater, all steelhead spawn during the spring months when daily water temperatures reach 6 – 90 C, usually about mid-April through May to early June.

Summer-run steelhead are relatively rare in Alaska and may be found in only a few select Southeast Alaska systems; annual returns of summer-run fish may vary considerably. Fall-run steelhead is the predominant form along the Gulf of Alaska west of Yakutat, including all systems on Kodiak Island and the Alaskan and Kenai Peninsulas. There are approximately 36 fall-run systems in Southeast Alaska but the spring component of these streams is thought to exceed the fall-run component. With the exception of the large transboundary rivers which originate from headwaters in Canada, the steelhead systems in Southeast Alaska all have a dominant spring-run component, even if a system has a summer or fall-run component.

Steelhead are “iteroparous” and may spawn more than once while Pacific salmon are “semelparous” and spawn only once and then die. The percentage of steelhead which return a second time to spawn typically ranges from 20 to 30% but may be as low 10% or as high as 50%. Generally the larger and older females survive at a higher rate than the smaller and younger ones, and males do not survive spawning as well as females.

The ragged and spent spawners, sometimes called kelts, move slowly downstream to saltwater, and the vibrant spawning colors return to a bright silvery hue as their depleted stores of fats are restored once they resume feeding. Most steelhead that spawn more than once come back annually but some may skip a year before returning to spawn.

While the adult steelhead are returning to their ocean feeding grounds and their spawning wounds are healing, the eggs which were deposited deep in the gravel during the spring quickly develop into alevins or "sac-fry". These tiny fish gradually absorb the yolk sac and work their way to the surface. By mid-summer the fry emerge from the gravel, minus the yolk sac, and seek refuge along stream margins and in protected areas. Mortality of steelhead fry is high as most of them are killed or washed from the stream each year. For those that do survive they may grow to be 2 to 3 inches by the fall before heading into their first winter. These juvenile steelhead typically will spend 2 – 5 years rearing in freshwater before smolting and returning to the ocean.

Given all the variables and complexities of the steelhead life cycle, including the many possible age classes, the possibility of repeat spawning, and the variation in run-timing, perhaps nature has designed the steelhead life history so that a harsh flood, winter, or drought does not severely impact a specific population.

Feeding Ecology
Upon emergence, the small trout fry assemble or school together in groups and seek shelter along the stream margins or protected lake shore, feeding on crustaceans, plant material, and aquatic insects and their larvae. Resident rainbow trout rear in similar habitat for the first two or three years then move into the larger water of lakes and streams and turn more to a diet of fish, salmon carcasses, eggs, and even small mammals. After they smolt and enter the open ocean, steelhead grow to be significantly larger by feeding on more nutritious squid, amphipods and other fish.

Migration
There is little information on the migration of Alaska steelhead away from our coastal waters to the open ocean. Steelhead are most abundant in the Gulf of Alaska and the eastern North Pacific and western Aleutian areas and generally found in the 50 C isotherm in the north and the 150 C zone in the south. When high-seas drift gill-netting was occurring large numbers of steelhead from the Pacific Northwest streams and Alaska were intercepted in this fishery; this indiscriminant fishing is no longer allowed. One anecdotal piece of the puzzle comes from a steelhead tagged in 1989 as it left the Karta River in Southeast Alaska. This fish was recaptured about 3 weeks later by a Japanese research vessel on the high seas of the Pacific Ocean.

[wetnose]

Range and Habitat
Rainbow trout are native to waters throughout Southeast Alaska west to Kuskokwim Bay, and as far up the Kuskokwim River as Sleetmute. The clearwater lakes and streams draining into Bristol Bay provide outstanding habitat. Rainbow trout occur naturally on the Kenai Peninsula, throughout the fresh waters of Upper Cook Inlet, on Kodiak Island, and in the Copper River drainage. Release of hatchery-reared rainbow trout outside of their native range has occurred in specific lakes and streams in the Tanana River drainage near Fairbanks, Kenai Peninsula, Kodiak Road System, Matanuska Susitna Valley, Prince William Sound, Resurrection Bay, Anchorage Bowl Sub-District, Chugiak/Eagle River Sub-District, Elmendorf Air Force Base Sub-District, Fort Richardson Army Base Sub-District, and the Turnagain Arm Sub-District.

Steelhead are found in the coastal streams of Alaska from Dixon Entrance northward and west around the Gulf of Alaska down to the Port Heiden and Cold Bay area on the Alaska Peninsula. There are no documented populations of steelhead on the Alaska mainland west of the Susitna River and north of the Chignik River system. This area is generally known as Bristol Bay and the populations of rainbow trout in this area do not migrate to sea and are considered resident rainbow trout. Alaska is unique in that it relies primarily on wild propagation of steelhead populations versus the lower 48 states where a majority of the steelhead populations are enhanced.

[wetnose]

Status, Trends, and Threats
Status
Wild populations of rainbow and steelhead trout in Alaska are generally believed to be healthy with only a few specific areas where fisheries managers are concerned. This is not the case elsewhere as both native rainbow and steelhead trout are considered threatened or endangered throughout most of their native range. The way to maintain healthy populations of trout in Alaska is to ensure that their habitat is preserved.

Trends
Based on the limited stock status information available, steelhead abundance in Southeast Alaska was relatively stable and slightly above average between 2003 and 2007 but has trended downward in recent years, closer to the 15-year average. There are still systems in Southeast Alaska that have not rebounded from the depressed levels observed in the late 1980’s and early 1990’s. Very little information is also available for steelhead stock status and trends throughout South Central Alaska but the populations are thought to be fairly stable with managers concerned with the number of returning adults to a few streams. Environmental changes in the North Pacific Ocean affect the survival of juvenile steelhead as they mature, thus impacting the number and size of returning adults.

Rainbow trout populations in freshwater are also thought to be stable throughout their native range in Alaska.

Threats
The biggest threat to rainbow and steelhead trout in Alaska is the degradation of their native habitat caused by human interactions and development including: urbanization, roads, hydroelectric projects, timber harvest, mining projects, and loss of wetlands.

Threats include habitat loss, habitat degradation, climate change, sport, subsistence and commercial harvest.

[wetnose]

Fast Facts
Size
Length up to 45 inches; Weight up to 55 pounds
Lifespan
4 - 11 years
Distribution/Range
Throughout the Pacific Rim from southern California through the Gulf of Alaska to the Kamchatka Peninsula in Russia
Diet
Zooplankton, insects, crustaceans, mollusks, fish eggs and other fish
Predators
Other fish, birds of prey, otter, mink, seals, humans

[xiaolu]

至于 Rainbow Trout, 我曾读过一数学公式, 用来计算鱼的长度和重量之间的非线性关系 (如果我们把钓鱼"休闲"和中学的数学运算"游戏"结合起来的话:-):

L: 鱼的长度 (英寸)
W: 鱼的质量(类似重量) (磅)
b: 固定常数 (接近 3.0)
c: 固定常数(大约 0.000426)

因此, 一条长度为 22 英寸的 Rainbow Trout, 其质量(重量)大约在 W = c x (L^b) = 0.000426 x (22^3) = 0.000426 x 22 x 22 x 22 = 4.54 (磅) = 4 磅 8.6 盎司

(注: 此非线性的公式直接说明的是, 鱼的长度大了一倍的话, 鱼的重量增长了 8 倍! 比如, 如果 22 寸长的 Rainbow Trout 是 4 磅, 那么 2 x 22 = 44 寸长的 Rainbow Trout 就是 4 x 8 = 32 磅)

[john8848]

钢头大，象三文，彩虹小，象河鱼。吃起来也一样，钢头象三文，彩虹象河鱼。

[XUYCA]

钢头大，象三文，彩虹小，象河鱼。吃起来也一样，钢头象三文，彩虹象河鱼。

区分内陆彩虹和SteelHead可以从大小，颜色以及身体花点分布。
以前讨论过很多次了。
内陆彩虹：平均1-3LB，颜色较深，花点分布头和全身。
Steelhead:属于早期海洋回流品种。平均4-8Lb，大的有15-20lb.颜色白，花点分布在身体上方。

[枫叶天堂]

钢头指的是移居到海洋里的本地土生的彩虹 。其实是一个东西， 就是因为环境变化而造成身体的变化（保护色） 其实说白了就只有一种： trout。 但是有人把 silver的彩虹叫钢头了 。但是安大略湖里的是放养的

比如说国内的中国人和这里的中国人。 咱们不会因为脱离了国家就变成加拿大人了， 始终离不开中国人的称号。 顶多就是北美华人

[wetnose]

谢谢枫叶总教官深入浅出的解释。

钢头指的是移居到海洋里的本地土生的彩虹 。其实是一个东西， 就是因为环境变化而造成身体的变化（保护色） 其实说白了就只有一种： trout。 但是有人把 silver的彩虹叫钢头了 。

比如说国内的中国人和这里的中国人。 咱们不会因为脱离了国家就变成加拿大人了， 始终离不开中国人的称号。 顶多就是北美华人

[wetnose]

感情你们天天嘴上说钓彩虹，钓上来的大部分是Steelhead,哈哈！看照片你们钓起的鱼Steelhead多于彩虹。

钢头大，象三文，彩虹小，象河鱼。吃起来也一样，钢头象三文，彩虹象河鱼。

区分内陆彩虹和SteelHead可以从大小，颜色以及身体花点分布。
以前讨论过很多次了。
内陆彩虹：平均1-3LB，颜色较深，花点分布头和全身。
Steelhead:属于早期海洋回流品种。平均4-8Lb，大的有15-20lb.颜色白，花点分布在身体上方。

[wetnose]

钢头大，象三文是因为生活环境像三文所致；彩虹小，象河鱼，因为彩虹就是在河里出生后长大。

钢头大，象三文，彩虹小，象河鱼。吃起来也一样，钢头象三文，彩虹象河鱼。

[阿华]

俺现在只能识别，公母，三文，棕鳟，彩虹鳟! 钢头不知道是不是身上没有一条彩虹的叫钢头，哈哈，学习中！

[枫叶天堂]

谢谢枫叶总教官深入浅出的解释。

钢头指的是移居到海洋里的本地土生的彩虹 。其实是一个东西， 就是因为环境变化而造成身体的变化（保护色） 其实说白了就只有一种： trout。 但是有人把 silver的彩虹叫钢头了 。

比如说国内的中国人和这里的中国人。 咱们不会因为脱离了国家就变成加拿大人了， 始终离不开中国人的称号。 顶多就是北美华人

俺是按照你的文章理解的

院长的解释最符合的

在颜色和躯体上区别 但在学名里属于一种吧

[边走边钓]

膜拜理科帖子，多谢分享

[wetnose]

边部长你太谦虚，你应该在什么加点什么？

膜拜理科帖子，多谢分享

[wetnose]

阿华，你把最难的雌雄都分辨的清楚了，分辨彩虹和刚头就更不在话下了，哈哈！

俺现在只能识别，公母，三文，棕鳟，彩虹鳟! 钢头不知道是不是身上没有一条彩虹的叫钢头，哈哈，学习中！